Skip to product information
1 of 4
Check Back Soon

Item Number: SP885

Organic German Butterball Seed Potato (lb)

First Place in Rodale's Taste Test

German Butterball Seed Potatoes are a creamy, yellow-fleshed heirloom variety introduced by David Ronniger in 1988. Known for their rich, buttery flavor and all-purpose versatility, these potatoes earned first place in Rodale’s Organic Gardening “Taste Off” and continue to be a top pick for home gardeners and chefs alike.

This dependable late-season variety thrives in full sun and well-drained soil. With consistent moisture, German Butterball delivers excellent yields and stores well after harvest. Its creamy texture makes it perfect for mashed potatoes, baked dishes, or golden roasted wedges—bringing outstanding flavor to any recipe.

Learn more about growing and caring for potatoes in the blogs and videos below.

  • Skin/Flesh: Golden skin with creamy yellow flesh
  • Texture/Flavor: Rich, buttery flavor with smooth texture
  • Best Uses: Excellent for baking, roasting, mashing, or any preparation
  • Maturity: Late Season (100+ days)
  • Storage: Stores well after harvest
  • Growing Conditions: Full sun, well-drained soil, and consistent moisture
  • Organic Certification: Certified organic and grown in the USA

Ready to boost your potato-growing skills? Don’t miss these helpful resources:

Explore our full selection of Certified Organic Seed Potatoes to find the perfect varieties for your garden.

Approved for Organic Agriculture by the Washington State Department of Agricultureusda.png 5 star service badge One million plants sold online trust badge Potato free ship Mix and Match Potato discount badge
Available to Ship After: 11/7/2025
Temporarily unavailable. Sign up for an email notification to be alerted when the item is available.
Quantity Discounts for Organic German Butterball Seed Potato (lb)
Buy 5 for $7.19 each
Buy 25 for $6.79 each
$7.99
/lb
Satisfaction guaranteed shipping

Check Your Zone Compatibility:

Shipping Information

Ships from Northern CA.

 

Cannot ship to the following states: AK, HI, ID, PR, VI, GU

Shipping Weight: 1.28 lb

Dimensions: 7.0"L x 5.0"W x 5.0"H

Features

  • Container Compatible
  • Flavor Pick
  • For Baking (starchy)
  • Good for Beginners
  • Good Keeper
  • Roasting/Mashing (all-purpose)

Characteristics

Organic Status: Certified Organic Product
USDA Growing Zone: 3 - 9
Approximate Harvest Time : Late Spring
Approximate Harvest Time : Late Summer
Flesh Color : Yellow
Planting Time : Fall
Planting Time : Spring
Potato Size : Medium
Skin Color : Yellow
Organic Certifier: WSDA, USDA

Planting & Care

  • Fall-planted spuds produce outstanding yields by May. If your area experiences hard winters (USDA Zones 1–7), or you tend to have long, wet spring seasons when rot might be a problem, plant potatoes in the spring.
  • One pound of seed potatoes will plant a row approximately 8' long with seed pieces spaced at 8 - 12" apart.
  • Plan on 1,200 lb/acre (600 lb of fingerlings) when rows are spaced 36" apart with 12" between plants.
  • Under optimal conditions, you can expect to harvest 10–15 pounds of potatoes for every pound of seed potato planted.

Guarantee

We guarantee the perishable items we sell to be in good, viable condition when we sell them. Perishable items include, but are not limited to, garlic bulbs, flower bulbs, seed potatoes, onion sets & transplants, bare-root trees, vegetable crowns, etc. If your perishable item arrives in substandard condition, take photographs and please contact us within 3 days of the purchase date (or delivery date) and we will provide you with a refund of the purchase price (excluding shipping costs), or a replacement. Accordingly, we urge you to open any boxes marked as ""Perishable"" immediately upon receiving them and inspect the shipment thoroughly (do not crack open heads of garlic, we do not accept claims on cracked garlic). Because some perishable items can deteriorate very quickly, we cannot accept any claims beyond the 3-day time frame as it becomes too difficult to determine if these items were delivered in substandard condition, or if they turned into such substandard condition because of having been improperly cared for or stored once delivered.

View full details

Customer Reviews

Based on 10 reviews
80%
(8)
20%
(2)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
E
ELLEN in Zone 6
Excellent response time

I received my order promptly and was able to get my spuds planted. I'm hopeful having never fall planted before. The seed potatoes were in excellent shape.

D
Dianna
Favorite Potato

One of my families favorites it cooks well and my daughter claims it doesn't even need butter.

O
Oli
Awesome!

Fast shipping awesome customer service, i look forward to getting these in the ground

S
Selleck
First time buyer

1st time planting on this variety. Hoping for a good result.

E
EnvSciTeacher
Great potatoes

Bought these for my environmental science students to plant in their organic garden beds. Customer service was great. Potatoes arrived in great conditions. Reasonable price for my teacher's budget.