Why Do Onions Vary in Flavor & Storage Time?

Growing Onions: Choosing the Right Variety for Your Climate and Needs

Onions are a versatile and essential part of many cuisines, but did you know that their growth and flavor depend heavily on your location and the variety you choose? In our video, Growing Onions, Leeks, & Shallots, Tricia explains how to select onion types that thrive in your climate. Understanding whether your region is better suited for short day onions, long day onions, or intermediate day onions is the first step toward a successful onion harvest.

Understanding Day Length and Onion Growth

The type of onion you grow should align with the length of daylight hours in your region during the growing season. Here’s a breakdown of the three main types of onions:

1. Short Day Onions

• Best for regions closer to the equator, like Texas.
• Begin bulbing when daylight reaches 10–12 hours.
• Typically sweeter with higher water content but shorter storage life.
• Popular varieties: Vidalia and Texas Super Sweet.

2. Long Day Onions

• Thrive in northern regions like Minnesota, where summer days are long.
• Require 14–16 hours of daylight to start bulbing.
• Known for their stronger flavor and excellent storage capabilities.
• Popular varieties: Yellow Globe and Walla Walla.

3. Intermediate Day Onions

• Suited for areas with moderate daylight hours, bridging the gap between short and long day regions.
• Share characteristics with long day onions but can adapt to wider climates.
• Popular varieties: Candy and Super Star.

Our video includes an animated map to help you identify the best onion type for your location, ensuring a productive harvest.

What Determines an Onion's Flavor?

Shop Walla Walla Onion Seeds

The unique flavor of an onion is influenced by several factors, including its water content, sulfur levels in the soil, and sugar content. Let’s explore how these elements contribute to the flavor and texture of your onions.

1. Water Content

• Onions with higher water content tend to be sweeter.
• Water dilutes sulfur compounds, resulting in a milder onion flavor.
• For example, Walla Walla onions, with their 85% water content, are famously sweet and mild.

2. Sulfur Levels in the Soil

• Sulfur gives onions their characteristic pungency.
• Low-sulfur soil produces milder onions, as seen with Georgia’s Vidalia onions, grown in naturally low-sulfur regions.
• Soil Testing Tip: Test your soil’s sulfur levels to understand how it might impact your onions’ flavor. Avoid sulfur-rich fertilizers, as advised by Betty Jacobs in her book All The Onions. Stop fertilizing about 30 days before harvest to maintain the desired flavor profile.

3. Sugar Content

• Sweet onions have significantly more sugar (6–15%) compared to storage onions (3–5%).
• Higher sugar content contributes to their deliciously sweet flavor, making them a favorite for raw consumption or gentle caramelization.

Storage Considerations

The ability to store onions depends on their water content and sugar levels:

Short Day Onions

• Sweet and high in water content, these onions are highly perishable.
• Storage Life: Typically last only a couple of months unless kept in atmosphere-controlled coolers.
• Best Use: Enjoy fresh and in-season for maximum flavor.

Long Day Onions

• With lower water content and higher sulfur levels, these onions are storage champions.
• Storage Life: Last for several months when stored in a cool (36–45°F), dry environment.
• Best Use: Ideal for long-term storage and use in cooking throughout the winter months.

Knowing your storage needs will help you decide which type of onion to grow.

Tips for Growing Onions

Growing onions successfully requires attention to soil, watering, and fertilization practices. Follow these tips to maximize your yield:

1. Prepare the Soil: Onions prefer loose, well-drained soil rich in organic matter. Avoid compacted soil, as onions need space to form bulbs.
2. Test Your Soil: Regular soil testing can reveal nutrient levels, including sulfur, helping you adjust your fertilization plan for optimal flavor.
3. Provide Adequate Water: Onions need consistent moisture but should not sit in waterlogged soil, which can cause rot. Mulch helps retain soil moisture and regulate temperature.
4. Fertilize Wisely: Use nitrogen-rich fertilizers early in the growing season to promote green growth. Avoid fertilizers with sulfur if you’re aiming for milder onions, and stop fertilizing about a month before harvest.
5. Weed Regularly: Onions are shallow-rooted and struggle to compete with weeds. Keep the area weed-free for better growth.

Choosing the Right Onion Variety

Your choice of onion variety should depend on your climate, flavor preference, and storage needs. Here are some recommendations:

• For Sweet Onions: Choose short day varieties like Vidalia or Walla Walla.
• For Stronger, Pungent Onions: Opt for long day varieties like Yellow Globe or Redwing.
• For Versatility: Intermediate day varieties like Candy are excellent for a range of climates and uses.

Cooking and Enjoying Onions

Onions are incredibly versatile in the kitchen. Use sweet onions raw in salads, sandwiches, or salsas to enjoy their mild flavor. Stronger onions are best suited for soups, stews, and caramelization, where their bold taste enhances the dish.

Don’t forget to try your hand at preserving onions through pickling or freezing for extended use.

Why Grow Onions at Home?

Growing onions at home gives you control over the flavor, quality, and variety of your harvest. You can experiment with soil conditions to fine-tune the sweetness or pungency of your onions, and enjoy the satisfaction of cultivating a staple ingredient. Plus, homegrown onions are fresher, tastier, and often more economical than store-bought options.

Final Thoughts

Understanding the differences between short day, long day, and intermediate day onions can significantly impact your gardening success. By choosing the right variety for your region, testing and amending your soil, and following best practices for watering and fertilization, you can enjoy a bountiful onion harvest that suits your flavor preferences and storage needs.

For more tips on growing onions, leeks, and shallots, check out our video and additional resources. Happy growing!